The Rose Bargain (The Rose Bargain #1) by Sasha Peyton Smith Also by this author: The Witch Haven, The Thorn Queen (The Rose Bargain #2)
Published by HarperCollins on February 4, 2025
Genres: Romantasy, Young Adult
Pages: 400 •Format: E-Book •Source: Overdrive
Goodreads
London, 1848—For four hundred years, England has been under the control of an immortal fae queen who tricked her way onto the throne. To maintain an illusion of benevolence, Queen Mor grants each of her subjects one opportunity to bargain for their deepest desire.
As Ivy Benton prepares to make her debut, she knows that not even a deal with the queen could fix what has gone wrong: Her family’s social standing is in shambles, her sister is a shadow of her former self, and Ivy’s marriage prospects are nonexistent. So when the queen announces a competition for Prince Bram’s hand, Ivy is the first to sign her name in blood. What a bargain can’t fix, a crown certainly could.
Ivy soon finds herself a surprising front-runner—with the help of an unexpected ally: Prince Bram’s brother, the rakish Prince Emmett, who promises to help Ivy win his brother’s heart…for a price. But as the season sweeps Ivy away, with glittering balls veiling the queen’s increasingly vicious trials, Ivy realizes there’s more at stake than just a wedding. Because all faerie bargains come with a cost, and Ivy may have discovered hers too late.
I used to be an avid YA reader, who then over the years pivoted mainly to adult, and romantasy before “romantasy” was even a word. Sometimes it can feel like I’ve seen it all, and while still enjoyable, many of the books I read can feel formulaic. Therefore, I was so thrilled to find The Rose Bargain to be a fresh, compulsively readable addition to both the YA category and romantasy genre, and its sequel is going to be one of my most anticipated reads of whatever year it’s released!
The synopsis touts the novel as a cross between The Cruel Prince and The Selection, and while those are certainly good comp titles, there’s a hefty dash of Bridgerton in here too! Set in an alternative era regency London where a Fae Queen took over after the War of the Roses, The Rose Bargain follows protagonist Ivy Benton during her debut season where she takes the risk of joining a competition for the Fae crown prince’s hand in marriage. Her motives are far from innocently romantic; she is desperate to win in order to elevate her family from scandal and financial ruin and help restore her sister’s reputation, which is tattered after a mysterious disappearance.
I really loved Ivy as a protagonist. She was smart, calculating, and showed a good mix of weighing the consequences of her actions with also sometimes giving in to her emotions (realistic for a girl of young debutante age, imo). She also grew up obsessed with stories of the Fae, and has a healthy skepticism when it comes to the Queen instead of fawning adoration/fear as most of society does.
For a four hundred page book (rather modest by fantasy/romantasy standards), the author did an incredible job developing both a compelling plot and a full cast of side characters. The princes of course were important and prominently featured, however Ivy’s interactions and relationships with the five other girls in the competition really shined. Olive, Faith, Marion and Greer- the fact that I can remember all of their names in and of itself is a testament to how well they were written (ha!) Each girl had different motives, fears, and strengths, and it was interesting to see how that impacted the competition but also aided their friendships that eventually formed. Their eventual banding together was a treat to read, and I’m really interested to see the role they play in future book(s) (not sure how long of a series this will be, it’s giving duology energy but I’m not sure if a sequel has even been announced at this point).
The concept of the “bargains” was also really unique and fascinating. Most citizens end up making a bargain with the Queen at some point during their life, though debutantes are expected to make them young when they debut and have them be something to help them catch a husband (straighter teeth, shinier hair, etc). The Queen’s price for these bargains range from the random to the cruel (a missing finger, never being able to turn left again, losing all of your childhood memories) and seem driven by boredom, a theme that permeates the book in regard to immortal life. Tethered into the lore of these bargains that the reader discovers through Ivy is that tragic story of her sister Lydia, who made a bargain she can’t remember that ended up being her undoing. Another motivator for Ivy’s participation in the competition is to somehow find out her sister’s bargain and undo it if possible.
The setting of the novel was excellently done. The glittering grandeur of ballrooms and parties juxtaposed against the sinister undercurrent of the Fae lore and magic. It definitely gave a Holly Black vibe when it came to the Fae, where they are eerie, otherworldly and unsettling and felt very dark fairy-tale-esque. I loved that this was really more of a historical fantasy novel more than anything. There was a tension that permeated the narrative and readers will feel how Ivy is always feeling like she’s a bit off-kilter in this courtly world that orbits around non-humans.
And the ENDING?! WOW I was really surprised! I’d like to reread this one day to see if I can pick up on clues that I may have missed! The last 10% of the book is a WILD ride and I’m truly fascinated to see how everything is going to play out in the sequel.
Overall: A fast-paced, atmospheric read with a darker take on Fae with a thrilling cliffhanger of an ending. This book reminded me of how YA can be incredible. I don’t buy physical copies of books too often these days, but I will 100% be keeping my eye out for special editions of this one (honestly I think it’s the perfect candidate for a beautiful special edition!)



















Leave a Reply