Published by Knopf Books for Young Readers on October 4th 2016
Pages: 391 •Goodreads
Everyone thinks they know Libby Strout, the girl once dubbed “America’s Fattest Teen.” But no one’s taken the time to look past her weight to get to know who she really is. Following her mom’s death, she’s been picking up the pieces in the privacy of her home, dealing with her heartbroken father and her own grief. Now, Libby’s ready: for high school, for new friends, for love, and for every possibility life has to offer. In that moment, I know the part I want to play here at MVB High. I want to be the girl who can do anything.
Everyone thinks they know Jack Masselin, too. Yes, he’s got swagger, but he’s also mastered the impossible art of giving people what they want, of fitting in. What no one knows is that Jack has a newly acquired secret: he can’t recognize faces. Even his own brothers are strangers to him. He’s the guy who can re-engineer and rebuild anything, but he can’t understand what’s going on with the inner workings of his brain. So he tells himself to play it cool: Be charming. Be hilarious. Don’t get too close to anyone.
Until he meets Libby. When the two get tangled up in a cruel high school game—which lands them in group counseling and community service—Libby and Jack are both pissed, and then surprised. Because the more time they spend together, the less alone they feel. Because sometimes when you meet someone, it changes the world, theirs and yours.
I missed the All the Bright Places bandwagon, so Holding Up the Universe is my first encounter with Jennifer Niven’s writing. While it featured two interesting protagonists who had unique circumstances surrounding them, it was an enjoyable contemporary read that didn’t exactly blow me away in the sea of options available in YA.
I remember when I first read the synopsis, I was sort of shocked, as Niven was using rather a rather extreme physical condition for her protagonist (Libby, who was at one point so overweight that she had to be lifted out of her house with a crane) and it almost seemed a bit insensitive of a premise to me. How does one begin to even imagine what that sort of situation is like, especially having one’s affliction gain such public notoriety? I was surprised to find that the novel didn’t really focus very much on Libby’s physical condition or overcoming it, rather more on the emotions behind her overeating and her integration back into a social setting with her peers. I really loved Libby as a character and I loved that she was really OK with how she looked because she was more focused on how she felt, and she was a protagonist who actively checked in with herself and partook in self-care. Whether it was when she was being bullied at school or had just spent an emotionally exhausting afternoon teaching her peers about self-love and a healthy body image, she always checked in on her emotional state, which is something that I think a lot of teenagers don’t do or don’t know how to do, which was a great trait to showcase in a protagonist.
I found Jack to be much less underwhelming as a POV character. His inability to recognize faces and his coping methods for navigating relationships with other people was really interesting to read about, but he was such a total follower throughout most of the book that I found it hard to like him. Libby had 100x more strength than him and had arguably been through much more, so I almost felt like it lessened the impact of her story arc to have a romantic entanglement with him. There were also a lot of interesting and diverse elements brought up within Jack’s family system (gender/sexual identity, severe illness, biracial relationships) that were never fully fleshed out, rather it felt like they were included for the sake of making his family seem like they had this interesting and complex dynamic, but it was never truly expounded on. It just felt like Jack’s story could have been so much more than it was.
I think Holding Up the Universe could have been a much more powerful story had it NOT been a romance. I think Jack and Libby could have found each other and been friends who provided a strong support system for each other, but I was never convinced by their attraction or chemistry. It felt like a relationship of convenience (two people who happen to be on the extremely severe end of their affliction/disorders who find each other) rather than one that formed organically. In some ways I felt it took away from Libby’s wonderful character development to have her like Jack after his initial behavior towards her, as well as shifted the focus from some of her larger goals and achievements, such as her determination to break the body stereotypes for dancing, finding creative ways to empower herself and other females who are self-conscious about her body image, and her truly admirable habit for fighting her own battles (literally).
Overall: While I enjoyed reading Holding Up the Universe and I would try another novel by Niven, I felt this story could have been stronger without the romance aspect, as Libby is a protagonist who serves to inspire and teach readers about the importance of self-acceptance and emotional self-care. While Jack’s character felt weak to me in comparison, I believe that was due to the foundations of an interesting and diverse background that were never truly built upon. A well written novel with some interesting elements, but I just felt like it had the potential to be so much more.
Reading this book contributed to these challenges:
- Goodreads Challenge 2016
I was really excited about this one for a while but keep hesitating now. I LOVED All the Bright Places as I was reading it but my feelings for it have definitely changed/faded over time. I’m not sure when I’ll read this one now haha.
Honestly this was just kind of MEH. I have All the Bright Places but everyone hypes it so much that I’m sort of wary to start it…
I completely agree with your thoughts. I wasn’t blown away by this novel either, but for different reasons than you. I never thought about how this would have been a stronger story hadn’t it been a romance, though, but I completely agree and I think it’s an excellent point. Great review! 🙂
Thank you, Karin! I felt pretty “meh” about this one, so I’m wondering if I’ll like All the Bright Places more or if I’ll be underwhelmed by that one as well.
I’m still on the fence wether to buy this one or not. I’ve heard so many reviews that its an ok book, but not great. Still thanks for adding your thoughts to the mix 🙂 Nice review!
Thank you Sarah! I’m glad I read it, but also glad I checked it out from the library 🙂 Have you read Niven’s debut as well?